Cite

American Reactions to the Quebec Act

By: Serge Dupuis

Serge Dupuis

Contributing Historian

Author of six books, and a wide variety of articles and reports, Serge Dupuis was selected as “inspiring path” by the Journées de la relève en recherche de l’ACFAS (2021). He has also won the following awards:

  • Canada Council for the Arts Scholarly Book Award (2024) for  Une histoire du Moulin-à-Fleur de Sudbury: quartier ouvrier, territoire canadien-français, published by Ottawa University Press (2025)
  • The Richard-Arès Prize for Best Essay published in Quebec (2018) for Le Canada français devant la Francophonie mondiale : l’expérience du mouvement Richelieu dans la deuxième moitié du XXe siècle, published by Éditions du Septentrion (2017)
  • Canada Council for the Arts Scholarly Book Award (2016) for Le Canada français devant la Francophonie mondiale (2017)

Serge has taught at universities across Ontario and Quebec from 2011 to 2017, then went on to concentrate entirely on the research, writing, and popularization of history throughout diverse forms of media since 2018.

Born in Sudbury (Ontario), Serge Dupuis is a professional historian working in Quebec; he is an associate member at the Chaire pour le développement de la recherche sur la culture d’expression française en Amérique du Nord (CEFAN) at the University of Laval.

Serge Dupuis has a bachelor’s degree (Laurentienne, 2007), a master’s degree (Ottawa, 2009) and a doctorat (Waterloo, 2013), then completed a postdoctoral fellowship (Laval, 2016); he received grants from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada for his three graduate studies.

What was the Quebec Act?

The Quebec Act reauthorized the Catholic Church to collect tithes, re-established the seigneurial system, allowed Catholics to obtain positions within government, recognized French law in civil matters, and enlarged the Province of Quebec’s territory to the Great Lakes basin and the Plains of the Midwest.

British, French and Indigenous motivations

In the late 1760s, colonial Americans were moving into Illinois country, pushing back and murdering Indigenous inhabitants, who grew increasingly angry. At the same time, in the thin strip of land along the St. Lawrence River assigned to the Canadiens after the British conquest in 1763, the former French colonists complained that they had been robbed of fertile lands to the south and west, where French settlers and voyageurs had long been living and operating[1].

As few were satisfied with this state of affairs, British merchants, French inhabitants, and Indigenous groups petitioned British House of Lords and Privy Council member Lord Dartmouth to restore New France’s former boundaries, customs, and laws within the new British colony. The British House of Lords took up the issue in 1773. Governor Guy Carleton was persuasive in his defence of codifying accommodations he and his predecessors had introduced in the St. Lawrence Valley since 1763. Opposition in the House of Commons, where fears surrounding despotism and awarding more land to the French and Indigenous were expressed, did not coalesce into a viable alternative for British North America.

In London, Lord North’s government supported the Quebec Act, as it did not infringe on the existing 13 American colonies. Furthermore, as the Irish experience of managing a Catholic population had resulted in poverty, political insurrection, and perpetual military presence, the legislators were open to trying a more flexible, less intrusive form of governance for French and Indigenous subjects.

Painting by James Hunter, A View of the Basin of Quebec Taken from the Citadel Shewing Beauport Shore, Isle of Orleans & Point Levi, c. 1779. Image courtesy of Library & Archives Canada.

American Support

The Quebec Act did find support in Britain and among some colonial Americans. A Harvard-educated son of a former Massachusetts governor, Thomas Bernard, stressed that accommodations offered to the French were “subject to the King’s supremacy.” As “four hundred emigrants, because they are Protestants, [could] erect themselves into a constitutional aristocracy, and tyrannize over and oppress” the “hundred thousand peaceable and dutiful subjects, who first settled the country; men of property, of rank, of character,”[2] the Quebec Act encouraged liberty and prevented oligarchy.

Furthermore, Bernard argued, attaching Labrador, the Great Lakes, and the Ohio River Valley to Quebec was practical, as the French fishermen and traders knew the riverine networks of the interior, and were seen as legitimate interlocutors to their Indigenous allies.[3] Colonial American squatters, on the contrary, were seen as hostile aggressors, and still remained too few to justify new British colonies.

A former provost marshal in Georgia, William Knox, found little to emulate in the Irish experience of governing Catholic populations, repression having “so little served to attach these infatuated people to the English government and their fellow-subjects.”[4] As Catholic inhabitants in Quebec outnumbered Protestants 500 to one, it was more useful to find inspiration in Minorca, whose tiny Catholic population had become peaceful and neutral after its transfer from Spain to Britain in 1713 and the introduction of measures of tolerance.

American Opposition

Colonial Americans opposing the Quebec Act were more numerous and vocal. Most criticism centred on issues of democratic governance, territorial use and authority, and religion.

As professor Kristofer Ray writes,

The Quebec Act was the victim of poor timing: its centralizing tendency ran exactly counter to the radical arguments gaining steam in the thirteen seaboard colonies.[5]

The Quebec Act’s reintroduction of French civil law in the province was also depicted as an effort by “authoritarian Whigs” to limit participatory politics, divide colonial subjects, and reinforce the colonies’ subordination to Britain. “Colonial newspapers used the Quebec Act as a metaphor for continuing loss of liberty within Britain’s North American colonies,”[6] professor Paul Langston writes. “The enactment of the Coercive Acts earlier in 1774 and the enforcement of perceived tyrannical laws in Quebec confirmed, according to colonial papers, that colonists’ liberties were being systematically eliminated.”[7] Benjamin Franklin opined that Americans should have a say over the form of government in Quebec, “having assisted in the conquest of Canada, at a great expense of blood and treasure.”[8]

The Quebec Act’s extension of the province’s boundaries also countered the 13 colonies’ hopes for trans-Appalachian expansion and emboldened Indigenous nations who resisted American expansion and often remained allied with French traders. Tolerating Catholics in Nova Scotia or a limited Quebec was one thing, but “that this French arbitrary government may take in as much of America as possible,” with limits “extended southward to the Ohio, and westward to the Mississippi,” until it “comes to be filled up with [its] inhabitants,”[9] was unbearable, argued Reverend Ebenezer Baldwin of South Carolina.

Maps developed during this time reinforced fears. “While the Act loomed large in the colonial mind,” professor Jeffers Lennox points out, its cartographic treatment was not “thorough”[10] and reinforced the sense that the American colonies were being constrained and surrounded. Ezra Stiles’s map “depicted Quebec as blood red, line an open wound threatening to drown the light-green Protestant colonies as it enveloped them on all sides,”[11] and William Faden’s showed “just how large Quebec had become,”[12] but John Cartwright’s “illustrated the entangled nature of French, English, and Indigenous concerns” in an attempt “to create a federation that would address the needs of each group.”[13] Consequently, “Quebec came to represent a barrier against expansion, not a symbol of British strength or the increasing flexibility of imperial governance.”[14] As colonial agent Benjamin Franklin wrote, entrepreneurial Americans were likely to continue settling the interior, whether Britain allowed them to or not. To contain growing American hostility, he recommended two amendments to the Quebec Act: the reduction of “that Province to its ancient limits”[15] and the creation of a Protestant legislature so that “a free government [be] granted to Canada.”[16]

Finally, colonial Americans feared having an openly Catholic neighbour. At the first Continental Congress, held in September/October 1774 in Philadelphia, delegate John Adams deplored the Quebec Act as a “danger to us all.” Its “prerogative to give any government to a conquered people” was ludicrous, especially if it meant, in his view, the reintroduction of “feudal Law and Romish superstition” and “orders of military monks.”[17]

While the idea that 70,000 French inhabitants, French Catholic clergymen, and their Indigenous allies could “enslave”[18] 2.5 million British Americans into a despotic government was itself ludicrous, such fears became widespread in the press. The Quebec Act would become associated as one of a number of “intolerable acts” imposed on the American colonies to reinstate order in the fallout of the 1773 Boston Tea Party.

Portrait of General James Wolfe (painted by J.S.C. Schaak) directing operations in Quebec City, c. 1766. Image courtesy of Library & Archives Canada.

The Quebec Act “catalyzed latent but powerful”[19] anti-Catholic sentiment in the New England press. For example, in October 1774, the New York Journal reported on the return of Guy Carleton from London to Montreal. Here was a soldier in James Wolfe’s army on the Plains of Abraham in September 1759, being reduced 15 years later “to be kissed by the Bishop,” Jean-Olivier Briand, who directed Carleton to sit “at his right hand in his chaise.”[20]

Such stories instilled fears, as the legitimization of a Catholic Church on the American colonies’ doorstep was represented as a revocation of settler colonialism, proof of the arbitrary governance by imperial authorities. It was, according to the Massachusetts Spy newspaper, “an act contradictory to his Majesty’s coronation oath […], repugnant to the rights, liberties, and religion of the nation.”[21] Protecting and promoting the Protestant faith was one of the King’s most important responsibilities and the sovereign was trampling it.

Legacy

The Quebec Act was instrumental in legitimizing colonial rebellion. “By the Quebec bill now passed,” wrote one reader of the Connecticut Gazette in January 1775, “there is no reason to believe that if any liberty for Englishmen is to remain, it must be in the North American colonies, where, I hope, the inhabitants will have virtue enough to exert their utmost strength to secure it to themselves.”[22]

The Quebec Act’s new model of governance for the British Empire might have served as an “accurate reflection of the local geopolitics,” Jeffers Lennox writes, but its “complicated image of North America,”[23] much like John Cartwright’s map, was unsuccessful at conserving British hegemony on the continent.

On the other hand, the Quebec Act was successful in convincing French Canadians and Indigenous populations to withhold from joining the American Revolution. And as some colonial Americans had feared, Catholic toleration did offer the Canadian Church “an unprecedented level of autonomy from the state”[24] and allowed it to develop ecclesiastical networks to the Holy See and other churches in the Atlantic world. The Quebec Act’s success at appeasing conquered peoples was imitated in the Relief Acts of 1778 and 1791.

The Mississippi and Ohio River valleys were ceded to the United States through the Treaty of Paris of 1783 that concluded the American Revolution, while the north of the Great Lakes that remained under British rule was divided into Lower and Upper Canada in 1791, the same year the first French-Canadian Legislative Assembly was created.


[1] Jeffers Lennox, “Seeing Red: The Quebec Act and Its Geographic Implications,” Entangling the Quebec Act: Transnational Contexts, Meanings, and Legacies in North American and the British Empire (2020), pp. 267–277.

[2] Sir Thomas Bernard, An Appeal to the Public, Stating and Considering Objections to the Quebec Bill (London, 1774), p. 15.

[3] Lennox, “Seeing Red,” p. 281.

[4] William Knox, The Justice and Policy of the Late Act of Parliament for Making More Effectual Provisions for the Government of the Province of Quebec, Asserted and Proved; and the Conduct of Administration Respecting the Province, Stated and Vindicated (London, 1774), p. 24.

[5] Kristofer Ray, “‘Our Concerns with Indians are new greatly extended’: Cherokees, Westward Indians, and Interpreting the Quebec Act from the Ohio Valley, 1763-1774,” Entangling the Quebec Act: Transnational Contexts, Meanings, and Legacies in North American and the British Empire (2020), p. 324.

[6] Paul Langston, “‘Tyrant and Oppressor!’: Colonial Press Reaction to the Quebec Act,” Historical Journal of Massachusetts, Volume 34, No. 1 (2006), p. 3.

[7] Ibid., p. 3.

[8] Letter from Benjamin Franklin to William Franklin, “Journal of Negotiations in London,” March 22, 1775, p. 540.

[9] Ebenezer Baldwin, “Appendix stating the heavy grievances that colonies labour under from several late acts of the British Parliament…,” A Sermon, Containing Scriptural Instructions to Civil rulers, and all Free-Born Subjects (New Haven, 1774), p. 67.

[10] Lennox, “Seeing Red,” p. 285.

[11] Ibid., p. 287.

[12] Ibid., p. 290.

[13] Ibid., p. 292.

[14] Ibid., p. 285.

[15] Letter from Benjamin Franklin to Jonathan Shipley, March 10, 1774, in The Papers of Benjamin Franklin, vol. 21 (1978), p. 139.

[16] Benjamin Franklin, Memoirs of the Life and Writings of Benjamin Franklin, vol. 1 (Philadelphia, 1818), p. 284.

[17] John Adams, Notes of Debates in the Continental Congress, October 17, 1774, Papers of John Adams, vol. 2: Founding Families (Boston, 2007).

[18] Lennox, “Seeing Red,” p. 278.

[19] Ollivier Hubert and François Furstenberg, Entangling the Quebec Act: Transnational Contexts, Meanings, and Legacies in North American and the British Empire (2020), p. 29.

[20] New York Journal, October 6, 1774, in Brad A. Jones, “A ‘Fit Instrument’: The Quebec Act and the Outbreak of Rebellion in Two British Atlantic Port Cities,” Entangling the Quebec Act: Transnational Contexts, Meanings, and Legacies in North American and the British Empire (2020), p. 233.

[21] Massachusetts Spy, September 8, 1774, in: Paul Langston, “‘Tyrant and Oppressor!’: Colonial Press Reaction to the Quebec Act,” Historical Journal of Massachusetts, vol. 34, no 1 (Winter 2006), p. 5.

[22] Connecticut Gazette, January 27, 1775, in Langston, “‘Tyrant and Oppressor!’”, p. 14.

[23] Lennox, “Seeing Red,” p. 293.

[24] Hubert and Furstenberg, Entangling the Quebec Act (2020), p. 28.